Friday, December 08, 2006

What's the Matter with Scarborough?

Pop Quiz: Which parliamentary delegation is more socially conservative: Calgary or Scarborough?

The answer according to yesterday's vote in the house of commons? Scarborough. Here's the break down. In cow-town, 6/8 members of parliament voted in favour of reopening the same-sex marriage debate. In Toronto's largest borough, 6/6 members voted in favour. Here's the kicker. The comparison between Calgary and Scarborough is fairly appropriate. Calgary saw some of the largest Conservative pluralities and Scarberia saw some of the largest Liberal pluralities. Indeed, of the Scarborough six only Tom Wappel (Scarborough-Southwest) didn't garner 50% of the vote in the last election. There are a couple ways to rationalize this:
  1. The Parizeau explanation: Yep. It's the ethnic vote. Two things are true of many new Canadians (Can I get away with generalizing for one second?). They are more socially conservative and they vote Liberal. The latter is less true than it used to be. However, they still form a large part of the riding associations out in Scarborough. Thus, it shouldn't be a big surprise that they'd nominate a social conservative.
  2. The Pragmatic Explanation: The party is trying to crowd out the Conservatives on the right by taking away ammunition.
Now, I don't know if either of these hold water. It could just be six independent decisions by local riding associations. I just thought it was curious and tried to figure out how that happened. Anyone else got a theory?

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

The reasons are far beyond it. This time around many candidates in Scarborough are worried that Tamil Canadians and Indo-Canadians might vote enmasse for Harper, which willelad toa rout of the Grits in Scarborough. Harper has reached out to these communities through Jason K and the response has been tremendous.

Anonymous said...

I know in the case of Tom Wappel, he already beats up on blind Canadian Veterans.
Even he is smart enough to know not to piss off whatever constituency may still support him. As incredible as it is to believe there are any.

Anonymous said...

In Scarborough people can run a monkey as a Liberal and it will win.

All views expressed in this blog are those of the author and the author alone. They do not represent the views of any organization, regardless of the author's involvement in any organizations.

All comments are the views of the individual writer. The administrator reserves the right to remove commentary which is offensive.

The author is not responsible for nor does he support any of the advertisements displayed on the page